Tuesday, August 7, 2012


{Click for the option to download this packet}

In order to teach effectively it is important to set clear expectations and establish consistent procedures and routines. Once those are in place it is helpful to have a plan for managing student behaviors.
I do love the clip chart and out of all the systems I have used (and I have tried many over the years) it was by far my favorite. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend it to any teacher. I find it fairly easy to manage and it does provide quick results. I love that it reinforces positive behaviors and can be transported to specialists, recess, etc. I think that carryover throughout the day is very important. This is especially true if you are departmentalized and the students travel to different teachers. 

include a clip chart to coordinate with your classroom} 

But, for me personally there were a few reasons that I felt there was a need “mix it up.”  Before I begin, I want to stress that the key to any successful behavior management program is that it works for YOU. 

And by “you,” I mean the collective you: the teacher, the students, the families & the school.

My reasons for making a change may or may not apply to your situation, but I figured I would throw them out there as “food for thought.”

Here’s why I stopped using the clip chart in my classroom:

  • First, and probably most importantly, I noticed my son would say things like, “I had to be math partners with ___ and I didn’t like it because he is always on red” or we would run into a classmate at a store and he would say to my husband, “That’s ____ she’s in my class. The teacher likes her because she never moves her clip down.” Hearing a student’s perspective outside the classroom was eye-opening. His words told me that kids, be it good or bad, define each other by their status on a behavior chart.  After putting this on my radar, I noticed several small indicators in my own class that confirmed it to be true...knowing glances when someone moved a clip, an collective gasp when a student who usually clipped up over and over and over was told to clip down...things like that.
  • I had avoided using names on my chart because I didn’t want parent volunteers to be privy to the “status” of other students and instead used numbers.  But, let’s face it, the numbers are not exactly a top secret code. Technically this is “data” and I do feel it should be kept confidential. 
  • I liked that the clip chart provided students with the opportunity to “clip back up” and avoid parent contact because I do think it helped students “pull it together.” However, I don’t think it offered an accurate overview of the day to parents. If a student is clipping up and down all day everyday then it will be reflected on his report card as a conduct grade. But is it fair to provide a less than stellar grade on a legal document without keeping the students’ families “in the loop” on the day to day stuff?
  • As I've mentioned before having strong routines and procedures in place and by being consistent, the need for a behavior plan sort of phases itself out. I don’t typically need to address behaviors much after we’ve been in school for 6-8 weeks because the students know the expectations and the room just sort of runs itself and everyone does what they need to do. Because of this I found that clipping up and down became more of a matter of opinion and “teacher mood.” It was too arbitrary and I felt that I needed something much more systematic and accurate.
  • Lastly, because the chart is an effective behavior modifier, it is used in many classrooms at my school. By the time they got to me as third graders it had become a bit stale. Clipping up lost it’s “razzle and dazzle” because they had “been there/done that” for so long. I felt we needed to shake things up a bit.
After taking these things into consideration I knew I needed to come up with something that...
  • was confidential 
  • could travel with the kids and carry over from the classroom to specials and back
  • provided effective feedback to the parents that was free from opinion
  • allowed for positive reinforcement / feedback
  • enabled me to track progress and have concrete data to back report card grades
  • is easy to manage

Ultimately, I decided to use a daily calendar/behavior log with numbers that directly relate to my expectaions. Each student has a monthly calendar in his/her communication folder. It’s located in a space that is easy to access and easy for parents to see. I designed the calendar so that you simply need to fold it on the line and can insert it over the folder flap.

If a child is not “meeting a classroom expectation,” I quietly address it by verbally reminding him of the expectation that he is not following. 

For example “You are expected to be on task during independent work time.” I then record the #7 on my whole-class chart. If the behavior continues I state, “I reminded you that the expectation is to be on task during independent work. Let's add it to your calendar as a goal to work on.” I then circle the #7 on my chart which signifies that I will be recording it on his calendar. 

If the same behavior continues throughout the day, I add tally marks next to the number. This shows the parent what the child’s day looked like. In the event that a child exhibits repeated behaviors or demonstrates a behavior that is dangerous, destructive or considered to be "bully-like" they complete a goal sheet. The goal sheet communicates more about the incident to the family and most importantly it is in the child's words. This helps to eliminate the phone calls and emails that say "I want to hear his side of the story" or "__ says she didn't do anything wrong." It also helps to remind the child that we must all take ownership for our actions, but that we can all make positive choices.

{Click for the option to download this packet}

I explain that because these are “expectations,” we don’t need to write on the calendar if they are doing what is expected. I don’t tie in extrinsic rewards because I think it is important for them to adhere to our established guidelines, not to earn a prize, but because that is what is expected of them as members of a learning community.

I really like the message it sends. 

This system provides me with data. It allows me to analyze specific students. I can pull them aside, have quiet/private discussions and work with them to set behavior goals. I provides the parents with a record of the day. I’m very happy with it overall.

I do think it is important to stress that this system works best AFTER the expectations have been clearly taught, modeled and time has been provided for them to internalize the procedures and routines within the classroom. For that reason, I intend to start the year with the clip chart.

I incorporate the language that I’ll be using with the calendars. Instead of saying, “clip down,” I will say, “You re expected to be on task during independent work time. Please clip down.”  


“Friends, we are all expected to respect our school. I noticed Kate took the time to put away some supplies she saw out of place. Please clip up Kate.”

I tell them beginning on day one that the clip chart will be our temporary tool for learning our procedures and routines, but that our goal is to be able to demonstrate all of the classroom expectations by ___ and at that time we will switch to a different method of tracking our progress.

I have found that this is a very easy to manage and highly effective system to use.

I have just updated this product to now include preprogrammed calendars for the 2014-2015 and the 2015-2016 school years AND added EDITABLE calendars so that teachers may include their own classroom expectations and wording.

The packet also includes: whole class weekly behavior tracking sheets (perfect for attaching to a clipboard and sending along to specialists as well as using in class) and individual tracking sheets and student goal-writing pages.

For more tips and ideas on organizing and managing your classroom please check out my Clutter-Free Guide

Follow my Teacher Store so you don't miss
Flash Freebies or Discounted Debut Items and view my easy-to-navigate online catalog.

Check out CFC's Helpful Series for Teachers: 


  1. I know what you mean! I am a clip chart fan too...I think I will pilot this with my enrichment class (we switch for reading intervention) If I like it as much as clips I will switch...
    Thanks for yet ANOTHER great idea!

  2. I think the kids will still pick up clues from your words, even if they can't see the charts. But you have greatly reduced the kids from having a constant visual reminder on how they compare to other kids in behavior!

  3. I LOVE this and it is very similiar to what I use with those quirkey individuals since most do not need the clip chart all year long. It is such a "cleaner and more organized version" than mine. Thank you so much for sharing with us all.
    BTW.. not sure if you meant to leave number 9 blank on the individuals weekly behavior log (" ...in group lessons") to allow for individualization by teachers or not - but it is the one sheet that does not have the expectation typed with the number.
    Thank you for this great tool that I will be using this year!

  4. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

  5. I love this. For years I used the pocket chart with card changes and sent home a daily conduct card in their homework folders. But this year I struggled with the idea of it all being so public. Mid year I did away with the chart, I had private conversations with students as needed, and I continued the daily conduct card. I really like your monthly calendars and recording sheets to keep record (for myself and families.) Thank you for sharing!

  6. Our school did away with clip charts and behavior calendars about three years ago. Now we use Responsive Classroom, which is effective, but not a cure all. At the beginning of the year, we do A LOT of talking and role play about making good choices and thinking about how you would feel "if someone did that to you." The big idea is to not humiliate the child in front of his peers. So, if a child is misbehaving I have a private conversation them. If the behavior is a big problem, I send an email (or four!) to the parent. In extreme cases, we notify the principal. I think different things work with different kids. Did I mention that we had to get rid of Big Bucks too? I miss my Big Bucks!!

  7. I LOVE it also! I made a comment on FB about using the stoplight (cards), clipchart, etc...about why my principal hates them all! I have always used the money/behavior system because it is pretty private. Kids earn money everyday for completing homework, reading, doing neat work, helping a neighbor, being a good role model, being the first group ready to learn, etc.. They lose money when they don't follow directions, are being disrespectful, use the restroom during class time, etc. The reason this system has worked so well for me....I have never had a student keep track of how much money everyone earns or pays out. Everyone can earn at least 2 dollars every day just for completing homework and doing their assigned reading. They store their money in an envelope and we have bank day every other Friday. Some are savers and some are spenders. And, yes, my son has shared with me about students in his classes these past few years about who is always in trouble, who is the best reader, who is so quiet, etc. :( Thanks for validating what my principal has told us all along. Now, I feel that he had more insight than we teachers were giving him. ;)

    Thanks so much!

  8. I have to say thank you again for all the time saving products you have made and given away for free. I was working on school work again today and I have printed, copied, and will be laminating so many of your items. I really appreciate all that you have done.

  9. I appreciate you bringing up the downsides of the clip chart. I have always felt like the blog world is very pro-clip chart, and it is good to hear the other side of it. In my large district of 15 elementary schools, clip charts are prohibited because of the first two reasons you talked about. I think it is important to consider all aspects and effects of a behavior management plan.

  10. I just found your site and have found valuable information! IT's great....However, I couldn't get your teacher pay teacher site to open. Are there problems that you know of? Thanks again for everything.


  11. I like this system. The clip chart is interesting, and I have one ready to try this year. I had concerns about having the visual reminder there for all to see all day -- sometimes you just have a bad day and seeing it over and over again can make it worse. My thought now is to use the clip chart for general behavior of the group in hopes of encouraging the kids to do well for the sake of the whole class. We'll see. Thanks for the ideas and words of experience! Very helpful.

  12. I have been enjoying your blog all summer and I'm consistently impressed with your ideas and products. Thank you so much for sharing your wisdom and creativity. You're truly talented!

  13. How do you place the behavior calendar in their folder? Is a label?
    Thanks! ;-)


You may also enjoy...

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...